Which vintage coat is warmest? Shearling, sheepskin, wool and cashmere compared, with the labels of our pieces
The warmest coat on our rail is a real sheepskin one: the fleece is wool, and on a sheepskin coat the fleece is the lining itself, one skin with the wool inside and the suede outside. Wool and wool–cashmere cloth come next; leather, faux fur, denim and cotton shells are as warm as their lining. Of the 43 coats and jackets in stock today, 3 are real shearling or sheepskin, 10 wool or wool-rich, 3 cashmere or a cashmere blend, 5 faux fur or synthetic, and 9 leather or suede, 11 denim, 2 other cloth — from the composition tag where we could read one, and from the material named on the listing where the coat is lined and the tag describes the lining.
Everything below is read from the pieces on our rail right now — the composition tag photographed on each listing, the material named in its title and the measurements taken flat by hand, in inches — and rebuilds itself as pieces are listed and sold. Sizes are the UK sizes on the listings, judged from the flat measurements; our model is 5′6″ and a UK 8. Where a sentence is about how a fibre behaves rather than about our pieces, it is a quotation from the named source, with the date we read it. We have not measured warmth, and we quote no figure for it. Updated 19 November 2026.
The ranking, and where each line comes from
1. Real sheepskin and shearling — 3 pieces today
The fleece on a sheepskin is wool. Woolmark: “The fibre's natural crimp traps insulating air in cold conditions while releasing excess heat and moisture in warmer environments.” (Woolmark, read on 10 November 2026). What we see on our own pieces: the fleece is the lining, the suede is the outside of the same skin, and there is no separate lining fabric between you and the wool — how to tell it from faux is on real vs faux shearling and leather. That is why it sits first: it is the only coat here where the wool is worn directly and in one piece.
2. Wool, wool–cashmere and merino cloth — 13 pieces today
The same fibre, woven into cloth and cut into a coat or a blazer. The International Wool Textile Organisation: “Crimp refers to the natural waviness or curliness of wool fibers, contributing to the fiber’s insulating properties by trapping air and enhancing warmth.” (International Wool Textile Organisation, read on 7 November 2026). The Campaign for Wool adds: “Wool can absorb 30% of its weight in moisture before feeling damp.” (The Campaign for Wool, read on 7 November 2026). Cashmere in the blend is a question of fineness, not of a warmth figure we could cite: under the US Wool Products Labeling Act a product may be labelled cashmere only if it is “the fine (dehaired) undercoat fibers produced by a cashmere goat” and the average fibre diameter does not exceed 19 microns (Wool Products Labeling Act, read on 7 November 2026). Our observation: on our wool and wool–cashmere coats and blazers the tag we could photograph describes the lining, not the cloth, so the table below names the material from the listing; only 7 of the 43 coats and jackets had a fibre tag for the shell that we could read.
3. Shells that are as warm as their lining — 27 pieces today
Leather and suede (9), faux fur and faux shearling (4), denim (11), synthetic (1), other cloth (2). A skin without its fleece, a pile fabric on a woven backing, or a cotton cloth: none of these is wool, so none of the sentences above applies to the shell. What you feel is the lining and what you wear underneath. We do not rank inside this group, because nothing on the labels we read would support it; the listing of each piece says which material it is, and a faux piece is listed as faux.
Our coats and jackets today, by warmth class
43 in stock. “On the label” is the composition tag as our OCR read it from the listing photos; a dash means no fibre tag for the shell could be read — on a lined coat the care tag describes the lining — and the material in brackets is the one named on the listing. Length is the length given on the listing, measured flat. Prices are live.
Sheepskin, Afghan and Penny Lane coats → · All women’s outerwear → · Men’s jackets and coats →
Knitwear: cashmere, merino, lambswool, acrylic
52 knits in stock, 31 with a composition tag we could read; of the 17 cashmere tags, 16 say 100% cashmere. Where the tag was not read, the class comes from the fibre named on the listing. The knit column repeats what the listing says about its weight (chunky, cable, fine); we have not weighed or measured thickness.
Cashmere knitwear → · All women’s knitwear →
What the sources say, as read
- “The fibre's natural crimp traps insulating air in cold conditions while releasing excess heat and moisture in warmer environments.” — Woolmark, “What is the Wool Fibre?”, read on 10 November 2026.
- “Crimp refers to the natural waviness or curliness of wool fibers, contributing to the fiber’s insulating properties by trapping air and enhancing warmth.” — International Wool Textile Organisation, “About wool”, read on 7 November 2026.
- “Wool can absorb 30% of its weight in moisture before feeling damp.” — The Campaign for Wool, “Wool facts”, read on 7 November 2026.
- “Merino wool is generally less than 22 micron, which shows just how soft this premium fibre is. […] Years of innovative breeding have resulted in some ultrafine Merino wools to be naturally even finer than cashmere.” — Woolmark, “What is Merino wool?”, read on 7 November 2026.
- “In the case of a wool product stamped, tagged, labeled, or otherwise identified as cashmere, if— (A) such wool product is not the fine (dehaired) undercoat fibers produced by a cashmere goat (capra hircus laniger); (B) the average diameter of the fiber of such wool product exceeds 19 microns; or (C) such wool product contains more than 3 percent (by weight) of cashmere fibers with average diameters that exceed 30 microns.” — Wool Products Labeling Act, 15 U.S.C. § 68b(a)(6) (Cornell Legal Information Institute), read on 7 November 2026.
- “The term “wool” means the fiber from the fleece of the sheep or lamb or hair of the Angora or Cashmere goat […] which has never been reclaimed from any woven or felted wool product.” — Wool Products Labeling Act, 15 U.S.C. § 68(b) (Cornell Legal Information Institute), read on 7 November 2026.
Questions about warm coats and knits
Is shearling warmer than wool?
Shearling is wool: the fleece of the sheep, left on its skin. So the question is really whether a sheepskin coat is warmer than a wool-cloth coat, and the honest answer is that the same fibre is at work in both — Woolmark describes how the crimp of the wool fibre traps air next to the skin and insulates — while the construction differs. On a sheepskin coat the fleece is the lining itself and the suede is the outside of the same skin; a wool coat is cloth, with whatever lining its maker sewed in. We have not measured the difference and quote no figure for it. Today we have 3 real sheepskin pieces and 13 wool and wool–cashmere coats and blazers on the rail. Sheepskin, Afghan and Penny Lane coats in stock.
Is sheepskin the same as shearling?
On our listings the two words sit on the same pieces: what we call sheepskin or shearling is a skin with its own wool still on it, and the check is the same for both — part the wool and you see skin at the roots. We write real sheepskin or shearling in the title when that is what we see, and faux when the pile sits on a fabric backing and the label lists a synthetic fibre. How we check it on the piece: real vs faux shearling and leather.
Is cashmere warm?
Yes, in the sense that it is wool: the US Wool Products Labeling Act defines wool as the fibre from the fleece of the sheep or lamb or the hair of the Angora or Cashmere goat, and the crimp that lets wool trap air applies to it. It is also a fine fibre by definition — a product may be labelled cashmere only when the average fibre diameter does not exceed 19 microns. What we can count: 27 cashmere knits in stock today; we have read the composition tag on 17 of them, and 16 of those say 100% cashmere. What the labels say on real cashmere. Cashmere knitwear in stock.
Is cashmere warmer than merino wool?
Not by anything we can measure, and we have found no source that puts a figure on it. The cited difference is fineness: cashmere must average 19 microns or less (US Wool Products Labeling Act), and Woolmark says Merino wool is generally less than 22 micron, with some ultrafine Merino finer than cashmere. Both are wool, so the crimp-and-trapped-air fact applies to both. In a jumper the thickness of the knit matters as much as the fibre, and our labels give you the fibre and the percentages, not the thickness: today 27 cashmere, 5 merino and 11 other wool knits are in stock, 31 of all 52 knits with a composition tag we could read.
What is the warmest coat material for winter?
Of the materials on our rail, real sheepskin — the wool fleece worn in one piece on its own skin — then wool and wool–cashmere cloth, then everything whose warmth comes from its lining: leather and suede, faux fur and faux shearling, denim, cotton and synthetic shells. That order rests on one cited fact, that the crimp of the wool fibre traps air and insulates (Woolmark, IWTO), and on what we see on the pieces; we have not measured warmth and give no figure. Today: 3 sheepskin, 13 wool and wool–cashmere, 27 in the lining group, out of 43 coats and jackets in stock.
Is a wool and cashmere blend coat warmer than pure wool?
We cannot say it is, and we have found no source that says so. What the blend changes by definition is fineness — the cashmere share must be the undercoat fibre averaging 19 microns or less — and feel. On our 3 wool–cashmere coats and blazers the tag we could photograph describes the lining, not the cloth, so the blend is the one named on the listing; the title of each piece gives it as the maker’s label does.
Are faux fur and faux shearling coats warm?
As warm as its lining and what you wear under it. Faux fur and faux shearling are a pile on a woven or knitted fabric, usually polyester, acrylic or modacrylic on the label, not a fleece on a skin, so none of the wool sentences above applies to them. We have 4 faux pieces in stock today, each listed as faux in its title or its material tags. How we tell real from faux.
How do I tell from the label which one I am buying?
On a knit, read the composition tag: it gives the fibres as percentages, and we have read it on 31 of the 52 knits in stock. On a coat or jacket the care tag usually describes the lining, which is why our table shows no composition for most coats and names the material from the listing instead; on sheepskin, part the wool — on the real thing you see skin at the roots. Every piece on this page links to its listing with the label photographed. How to date vintage clothing from its label.
Looking after them
Sheepskin and shearling: Specialist sheepskin or leather cleaner only. Air it out, keep it away from direct heat and let rain dry off naturally.
Wool and cashmere coats and blazers: Dry clean. Brush after wearing, hang on a shaped hanger and steam out creases.
Cashmere knits: Hand wash cold with a wool wash, press the water out in a towel and dry flat. Fold it rather than hang it.
Wool and merino knits: Hand wash cold or on the wool cycle, dry flat and fold rather than hang. No tumble dryer.
Leather: Wipe with a damp cloth, condition now and then and hang on a wide hanger. Specialist leather cleaner only, never the machine.
Suede: Brush with a suede brush and spot clean with a suede cleaner, no water. A specialist cleaner for anything bigger.
Faux fur and faux shearling: Shake out and brush gently; spot clean or a specialist clean. No tumble dryer, no iron.
Denim jackets: Wash at 30° inside out with similar colours and hang to dry. Skip the tumble dryer to keep the stretch and the fit.
The care line on each listing comes first: it is read from the label where the label says, and from the fabric where it does not. Every care label we have read, by material: how to wash vintage clothes.
Download the data
Every piece on this page, one line each, as a plain CSV: title, group, warmth class, the material named on the listing, the composition and country read from the label, construction, length flat, the size we listed it as, the price today and a link to the listing. Generated from the live catalogue, so it is as current as the tables above.
kitanesque-outerwear-labels.csv · 95 pieces · Free to use and quote with a link back to Kitanesque (CC BY 4.0).
Built from the labels and listings of our own pieces, rebuilt as they are listed and sold; prices and stock are live on each product page, so quote them with the date you checked.